EX Home | Search | FAQ | Email Prev. Page | Contents | Next Page
Letters


This is where EX shares some of its mail with the rest of its readers so that you, the fans, know what other fans are thinking.
  We love to get mail from our readers. However, please remember that EX is not a store and we do not sell the merchandise we review. Check your local comic and hobby shops (and other places that carry anime items) if you're interested in purchasing any of these products. And, if all else fails, you can try some of the stores available online. But please don't ask us to sell things to you. (The mark up would be terrible.)
  Thanks again, and keep those letters coming!


WHERE DO I SIGN UP?
From: Wil Chung (wchung1@uiuc.edu)

I can't find where to be added to the mailing list, since every time I click on a link that says 'mailing list', it kicks me to the home page, but there's no sign up there... so I'm just emailing to see if I can get on this way or if you can point me to where I can sign up to be notified when the next EX issue comes out.

Thanks for writing in; the problem should be fixed by now. And just a reminder to the other readers out there—signing up for the EX mailing list ensures that you're one of the first to know when a new issue comes out.


FOR THE FUTURE!
From: Michael Haenell (turbo@futureweb.com.au)

I am hoping that you or your readers could help me with a little information as I have searched numerous english language sites and magazines without success. I am looking for information on a show called CAPTAIN FUTURE (or The Adventures of Captain Future) by Toei Animation Co. I saw the show in Germany where it has a huge following. I would like to know if the show was successful in any english speaking markets, when was it shown? Who currently holds the copyright for the possibility of a video release? I know that a release on video is possible, but is it likely, in other words, was the show popular to any degree outside of Europe? Your assistance would be greatly appreciated.

I'm afraid I can't offer you any assistance here, so I'll turn this over to our readers. If you've got any information on this show, drop Michael a line and see if you can help answer his questions.


PROMISES, PROMISES
From: Aripa Vulpe (wingfox@ucla.edu)

You maintain a very impressive page. All the cool pics just make me green with envy. But I want to know why you haven't done anything on RURONI KENSHIN. It's quite popular here in the States. I don't recall one mention of this series from EX. Do you guys have a thing against samurais? Mechas can get really dull from all the overexposure.
  And there is only so much you can write on GOLDEN BOY, TENCHI, MACROSS, KOR, and SLAYERS before getting repetitive. Those are all very popular series and get more attention than they really need (or deserve). I would much rather read about more obscure finds. With the resources you have, I don't think that would be very difficult.
  And I'm still waiting for coverage on the old DR. SLUMP or any past Miyazaki films. "Look forward and look back" right? Make good on your promise.

I agree that some titles have received more than their share of exposure of late, however, that doesn't necessarily make them bad.
  This issue we're covering LOCKE THE SUPERMAN and GALAXY EXPRESS 999, both of which are old titles, so I don't think that we've neglected what we said we were going to do. As for covering the Miyazaki films, it gets more complicated with Disney owning the rights to them all now, but we do have a review of KIKI in this issue.
  We'll continue to keep working and maybe we can do a feature article on RURONI KENSHIN. But we have reviewed various KENSHIN things, including CDs and games, and we even have the updates for the current goings on in the manga series in our new Weekly Jump Update.


DVD: THE AVALANCHE
From: Taro Nobusawa (taro@gte.net)

As usual, an informative and well done issue. I do however have some questions regarding the article on DVD. A nitpicky point is that not all DVD have region codes, but for all practical purposes they do.
  That aside, I do wonder about the statement that LD has better surround sound capabilies. Is that true? Both LD and DVD can support Dolby Digital (AC-3). In addition, DVD can support it on the tracks besides the primary audio. LD, if using AC-3, takes up one of the analog tracks, so on the secondary audio (usually the Japanese) ends up being mono only.
  That was my only major question. The other regards the listing of KIKI'S DELIVERY SERVICE as a DVD release. Has this been confirmed? I hadn't heard anything regarding this, but it would be welcomed news. I like DVD, but am not abandoning LD either, for reasons covered in your article.
  Anyway, keep up the great work (I especially enjoy Scott Frazier's Beyond TV Safety column, it feeds my friends' and my fantasizing of getting into the industry.)

From: Toby Celeski (kagato@earthlink.net)

Love the magazine. I just wanted to put in my two cents worth on the DVD—Is it worth it for Anime? subject. Overall, I do like the DVD format, though I am still an avid LD collector, call me old fashioned. My only problem with DVD is the market that it's aimed at replacing VHS. DVD is only as good as it's mastered and so far, I've been quite unimpressed with some of the offerings in anime, ie TENCHI MUYO IN LOVE and NINJA SCROLL to name a few. In TMIL, Pioneer, even though having to remaster it to DVD format, still left an annoying bug currently found only on the English LD release. Notice when Mihoshi boards the bus in Tokyo and starts speaking, there is an annoying clicking sound for several seconds in the english track only, not on the original Japanese.
  As for NINJA SCROLL, the problem is with the 5.1 track. Many people seem to argue that it's great, until you realize that surround isn't supposed to take place of the front speakers. The first five minutes of the movie seems mostly to be carried by the rear speakers, Dolby 5.1 is supposed to help envelop you in the action, not force you to direct your hearing at the surrounds. Overall I think DVD will someday reign supreme in the choice of format for Anime titles, I just hope that the quality that is produced lives up to what DVD can do, and not be inferior to that of VHS, until then, I'm sticking with my import LDs.

From: Stephen A. Quashnick (q_ball@ix.netcom.com)

Hey, I love the online Mag. The article on DVD was the kind of info I was looking for, but I heard there was a copy protection lock on DVDs. Is this true? Thanx for having a great Site.

From: Keith Yatsuhashi (pdeac@concentric.net)

Thank you for your discussion of DVD. This is one format Anime fans cannot be without. I am interested to know if where you got the information on a DVD release of KIKI'S DELIVERY SERVICE. That title has neither been announced nor rumored AFAIK. I can only hope your info is accurate. Please email me if you can.

Most people (including some anime companies) liked our DVD article. A few people wrote in with minor corrections and additional details, some of which we've reprinted above. As for me, I won't be giving up my LDs anytime soon (especially once I get my VAMPIRE MIYU TV LD box!)
  The information about KIKI being released on DVD was from a preliminary list researched by our staff. At this time, however, Buena Vista Home Video has not confirmed a release date for this title.


MACROSS PERFECT COLLECTION IS HERE—BUT NOT FOR LONG
From: Tim Neems (otaku@home.net)

In the current issue's letter's section you stated that MACROSS has never been subtitled. This of course is competely incorrect. Streamline released the ROBOTECH: PERFECT COLLECTION several years ago. Each volume has 2 of the ROBOTECH episodes and the corresponding episode from MACROSS, SOUTHERN CROSS, or MOSPEIDA uncut and subtitled. Now I have no idea if these are still available, or if they ever finished the all of the episodes, but they did get about 14 of each series completed, maybe more.

From: Z. Reddy (mrgone@concentric.net)

Regarding Keith Christy's letter regarding Macross:
Huh? Have I stepped into another dimension? Macross can easily be found subtitled, under the label ROBOTECH: PERFECT COLLECTION (I think it's published by Streamline). Perhaps they are not all available, but a good chunk of them are, each vid containing two original episodes subbed, and their American analogs dubbed as Robotech. A ridiculously expensive way to collect them, but they exist. Surely I'm not the only one to have noticed this... or maybe I am going delusional...
  A similar, related question though: how can I find Macross DYRL subbed? Egan Loo says a British version was made...

A lot of people wrote in to tell me that I was incorrect about MACROSS not being available subtitled in the United States. And I do mean a lot of people. MACROSS fans are some of the most dedicated I've ever seen. OK, so I was wrong about this, although I personally have never seen the "Perfect Collection."
  Nor am I ever likely to do so now. In an unusually fortuitously timed move, Streamline Pictures announced a moratorium on the ROBOTECH PERFECT COLLECTION series. This was done at the request of Harmony Gold, who owns the rights to ROBOTECH (and consequently the original MACROSS series) in the United States. So, if you're fortunate enough to find these collecting dust on a store shelf somewhere, you had best snatch them up post haste, as there aren't any more.
  As for the film DO YOU REMEMBER LOVE?, the British distributor Kiseki Films produced a (somewhat loosely translated) English-subtitled videotape for several Commonwealth nations in both PAL and NTSC formats. The key is finding an importer who sells the format your player can accept. (If you live in United States or Canada, that would be NTSC.)


ANIME VILLAGE NOT TRULY GLOBAL?
From: Nick Carver (nickcarver@dial.pipex.com)

As an avid fan of ESCAFLOWNE I was overjoyed to read of Bandai's distribution of this series through their Anime Village company. With palms sweaty I tapped in the URL and headed on over. I filled in the 'local' registration form noting that there was no space for country but put it in alongside my hometown in the 'city' box, thinking nothing of it. So, now, enough with this divulging of personal info, I wanted the good stuff. I wanted release dates, prices, box set details, international shipping costs? While perusing the ordering FAQ I was crushed (think of Dilandau's most agonised expression and you're not even close) to discover that the products (my beloved Esca included) were only available for residents of the US and Canada. Now, living in merry-old-Engerland I, like many other non-US/Canadian anime fans am very disappointed. I know that Bandai only want to sell direct to fans and that translating anime both in language and in format (NTSC,PAL,SECAM etc) is probably more work than Anime Village/Bandai want to undertake, at least for the moment. I'm not asking for a conversion of the tapes to PAL format - most anime fans in the UK have an NTSC compatible video as the state of the market is not as healthy as the US one, to say the least.
  But it seems unfair that a company offering the superb wares of a company as celebrated as Sunrise cannot cater to the huge number of fans who do not live in America or Canada. There is a point to this (honest). Anime Village say that they are always keeping up to date with fans wishes and suggestions through newsgroups, bulletin boards and even the mighty EX itself. So, if they are true to their word and fans of the shows available at the website who cannot currently order them make enough noise in the places Anime Village state on their site, then global ESCA, GUNDAM et al should be a thing of the near future. Well, that's the theory.
  Keep up the excellent work.

Well, you're on the right track to getting the situation changed. If our overseas readers want things released overseas, you need to write to the companies that have the rights in the U.S. In many instances, however, companies only purchase rights for limited areas outside of Japan (such as North American or North and Central America and Europe). This is pretty obvious if you look at some of the titles that are available both in the U.S. and in Europe, but are released by different companies in each continent.
  I have yet to check with Anime Village on this, but if they give me a response, we'll be sure to post it to our news section, so stay tuned.


*   *   *


Our Mail Policy:

We read all of the mail we receive. Readers who submit mail may receive personal replies via e-mail, a reply in the letter column, or in some instances, both.
  All letters sent to EX (or any of its staff regarding the magazine) are eligible for inclusion in the letter column. Letters may be edited for clarity and brevity. If you don't want your e-mail address printed, please tell us. If you would prefer that your letter not be published at all, please inform us of this as well.
  By the way, we here at EX try to keep things on a mature, intelligent level. This includes the publishing of our mail. The following are sure-fire ways to disqualify your response from being printed in the letter column...

  • WRITE IN UPPER CASE. This will guarantee immediate rejection.
  • fail to use capital letters at the start of sentences or when using words like ranma and macross.
  • Use inane words and phrases such as 'Ranma sucks' or 'Robotech rocks'.
  • Use punctuation in an inappropriate and outlandish fashion !!!!??????
  • Profanity and personal attacks will also wind up in the trashcan.
In general, it's best that you have something to say. So let's hear from you!

EX Home | Search | FAQ | Email Prev. Page | Contents | Next Page